S.No | AFT CASE | DESCRIPTION | OA No. | No.of APPL | COORDINATOR & LEAD LITIGANT | JUDGEMENT DATE | REMARKS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | AFT-2 | BROAD BANDING BENEFIT TO ALL DISABLED SOLDIERS | 166/2016 | 103 | COL N SITARAMAIAH LT COL ASHOK KUMAR SABHARWAL | 04-11-16 | AFT JUDGEMENT IN FAVOUR OF TSEWA, Rs.3.45 CRORES RELEASED TO TSEWA MEMBERS Click on this link to open judgement |
2 | AFT-2 (A) | BROAD BANDING BENEFIT TO ALL DISABLED SOLDIERS (BB-2) | 1677/2016 | 153 | COL AJIT SINGH RANA LT COL SASHI CHAUDHARI | 30-08-17 | AFT JUDGEMENT IN FAVOUR OF TSEWA Click on this link to open judgement |
3 | AFT-2 (B) | BROAD BANDING BENEFIT TO ALL DISABLED SOLDIERS (BB-3) | 003/2018 | 158 | COL AJIT SINGH RANA BRIG M K GANJU | 05-01-18 | Case disposed off with liberty to file individually Click on this link to read court order dated 05 Jan 2018. |
4 | AFT-12 | LT COL PENSION FOR PRE-1996 RETIREE MAJORS WITH MORE THAN 21 YEARS COMMISSIONED SERVICE | 276/2017 MA 227/2017 | 72 | MAJ PM GOSWAMI SQN LDR SARAT CHANDRA VARMA | 15-03-19 | Case disposed off with liberty to file after SC Judgement Click on this link to open judgement |
5 | AFT-3 | BROAD BANDING BENEFIT TO ALL DISABLED SOLDIER WHO GOT PMR | 168/2016 | 16 | COL AJIT SINGH RANA LT COL ATUL CHAUDHARY | 17-05-19 | Case disposed off Click on this link to open judgement |
6 | AFT-11 | GETTING PENSION OF LT AND CAPT TO ALL THOSE PRE - 2006 HONY LTS & CAPTS | 789/2017 Refiled as OA 1475/2018 | 26 | HONY CAPT B JOSEPH SM/HONY LT TSHERING DADUL BHUTIA | 04-09-18 | Case Refiled as OA 1475/2018 Order dated 30-05-2017 |
7 | MSP-MG (ARMY-1) | NOTIONAL MSP TO ALL MAJ GENS, LT GENS, AND LT GEN (HAG) AND THEIR EQUIVALENTS IN THE NAVY AND THE IAF | 1127/2022 | 43 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, MAJ GEN ASHOK MEHTA Filed on 11th March 2022 | 14-03-23 | Case disposed off Click on this link to open judgement |
8 | MSP-MG (ARMY-2) | NOTIONAL MSP TO ALL MAJ GENS, LT GENS, AND LT GEN (HAG) AND THEIR EQUIVALENTS IN THE NAVY AND THE IAF | 1128/2022 | 41 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, MAJ GEN RAM KUMAR KOHLI Filed on 11th March 2022 | 14-03-23 | Case disposed off Click on this link to open judgement |
9 | MSP-MG (NAVY) | NOTIONAL MSP TO ALL MAJ GENS, LT GENS, AND LT GEN (HAG) AND THEIR EQUIVALENTS IN THE NAVY AND THE IAF | 1126/2022 | 5 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, RADM JAGMOHAN SINGH SODHI Filed on 11th March 2022 | 14-03-23 | Case disposed off Click on this link to open judgement |
10 | MSP-MG (IAF) | NOTIONAL MSP TO ALL MAJ GENS, LT GENS, AND LT GEN (HAG) AND THEIR EQUIVALENTS IN THE NAVY AND THE IAF | 1266/2022 | 12 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, AVM JAGJIT SINGH GANDYOK, AVSM,VSM Filed on 11th March 2022 | 14-03-23 | Case disposed off Click on this link to open judgement |
Table Of Legal Cases
SL NO | AFT CASE | DESCRIPTION | OA No. | No.of APPL | COORDINATOR & LEAD LITIGANT | REGN DATE | LAST HEARING | NEXT HEARING | REMARKS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | AFT-1 | ENHANCEMENT OF PENSION (OFFICERS) | 34/2016 | 799 | BRIG SKS RANA,VSM | 08-01-2016 | 28-04-2023 | 17-07-2023 | Since the Hon'ble Judicial Member is holding the Court at Armed Forces Tribunal, Regional Bench, Kolkata, this Bench has not assembled today. * List for hearing as per seriatim. |
2 | AFT-3 (A) | BROAD BANDING BENEFIT TO ALL DISABLED SOLDIER WHO GOT PMR (PMR 1A) | 949/2017 MA 740/2017 MA 741/2017 | 14 | COL AJIT SINGH RANA LT COL RUDRA PRATAP SINGH | 30-05-2017 | 10-10-2017 | 26-10-2023 | Heard- (Reserved) |
3 | AFT-6 | GETTING PENSION OF COL (TS) TO ALL PRE - 16 DEC 2004 LT COLS | 664/2016 | 301 | LT COL K P RADHAKRISHNAN | 06-07-2016 | 02-11-2023 | 08-01-2024 | Arguments heard. Reserved for orders. |
4 | AFT-8 | GETTING PENSION OF NB SUB TO PRE - 2006 HONY NB SUBS | 1545/2016 | 126 | HONY CAPT B JOSEPH HONY NB SUB ARVIND MOHAN | 23-11-2016 | 04-02-2020 | The matter has been referred to Larger Bench in connected matters | The matter has been referred to Larger Bench in connected matters |
5 | AFT-8 (A) | GETTING PENSION OF NB SUB TO PRE - 2006 HONY NB SUBS - (HNS-2) | 1816/2018 | 61 | HONY CAPT B JOSEPH HONY NB SUB FAUJI RAM | 13-11-2018 | 22-08-2023 | 29-11-2023 | The matter in issue is subjudice before the Larger Bench in OA 589/2019 . In view thereof, re-notify the matter after the disposal of the issue in question in relation of the prayer made by the applicants seeking the grant of pension to the rank of Naib Subedar, inasmuch as the applicants were Hony Naib Subedars. |
6 | AFT-10 | GETTING PENSION OF SUB & SUB MAJ TO PRE - 2006 HONY SUBS, HONY SUB MAJS | 599/2017 | 56 | HONY CAPT B JOSEPH HONY SUB MAJ PRITI SINGH | 20-04-2017 | 06-11-2023 | 01-12-2023 | As the Ld. Principal Registrar is on official duty at AFT, Regional Bench, Jaipur, the Court has not assembled today. |
7 | AFT-11 (A) | GETTING PENSION OF LT AND CAPT TO ALL THOSE PRE - 2006 HONY LTS & CAPTS | 1475/2018 Old Case No.789/2017 | 43 | HONY CAPT B JOSEPH SM/HONY LT TSHERING DADUL BHUTIA | 30-08-2018 | 19-04-2023 | 22-05-2023 | (No update) |
8 | AFT-13 | GETTING PENSION OF LT COLS TO ALL THOSE PRE - JAN 2000 MAJS WHO PUT IN 20 YEARS | 457/2017 | 75 | MAJ PM GOSWAMI MAJ ASHOK KUMAR GADHOK | 23-03-2017 | 19-10-2023 | 28-11-2023 | Even though the matter is listed for hearing at 2.15 P.M. today but it is not possible to hear the matter at 2.15 P.M as there are already some Part Heard matters to be heard at 2.15 P.M. |
9 | AFT-14 (ARMY) | GETTING PENSION OF LT COLS TO ALL PRE - 16 DEC 2004 MAJS | 661/2017 MA 561/2017 | 69 | MAJ PM GOSWAMI MAJ SUDARSHAN KUMAR SHARMA | 28-04-2017 | 19-10-2023 | 05-02-2024 | The Bench has not assembled today due to non-availability of Hon’ble Member (A). |
10 | AFT-14 (NAVY) | GETTING PENSION OF LT COLS TO ALL PRE - 16 DEC 2004 MAJS-NAVY | 1228/2017 | 59 | MAJ PM GOSWAMI LT CDR BAL CHANDRA PANDEY | 25-07-2017 | 01-11-2023 | 04-12-2023 | List for hearing as per seriatim.Submissions have been partly addressed on behalf of the either side. As the matter appears to be similar to OA 1227/2017, it be re-notified with the same on 04.12.2023 at 12:00 P.M. |
11 | AFT-14 (IAF) | GETTING PENSION OF LT COLS TO ALL PRE - 16 DEC 2004 MAJS- AIR FORCE | 1227/2017 | 22 | MAJ PM GOSWAMI SQN LDR SURESH KUMAR KAPOOR | 25-07-2017 | 27-10-2023 | 04-12-2023 | Due to non-availability of Hon’ble Member (A), the Bench has not assembled today. |
12 | AFT-19 | GETTING PENSION OF MAJ TO ALL THOSE PRE-16 DEC 2004 CAPTS WHO PUT IN SIX YEARS COMMISSIONED SERVICE | 679/2017 | 45 | MAJ PM GOSWAMI CAPT HOSHIAR SINGH ATRI | 01-05-2017 | 19-10-2023 | 05-02-2024 | The Bench has not assembled today due to non-availability of Hon’ble Member (A). |
13 | AFT-28 | PAY FIXATION DISPARITY - MAJOR'S 5TH CPC (ARMY) | 181/2019 | 15 | MAJ PM GOSWAMI LT COL RAJESH CHUGH | 30-01-2019 | 08-11-2023 | 07-03-2024 | 07-03-2024 |
14 | AFT-28 | PAY FIXATION DISPARITY - MAJOR'S 5TH CPC (IAF) | 36/2019 | 8 | MAJ PM GOSWAMI, SQN LDR SURESH KUMAR KAPOOR | 09-01-2019 | 08-11-2023 | 07-03-2024 | 07-03-2024 |
15 | AFT-7 | GETTING SPECIAL FAMILY PENSION TO SINGLE LADIES WHOSE HUSBANDS DIED IN SERVICE | 66 | LT COL M P S BHATIA, SMT URMIL GILANI | 18-09-2017 | 15 Cases filed Separately | 15 Cases filed Separately | ||
16 | AFT-15 | GETTING BENEFIT TO ALL PRE - 2006 SEPOYS TO HAVILDARS OF ACP AVAILABLE TO POST - 2006 NCOS & OR | 949/2019 | 32 | HONY CAPT B JOSEPH HAV CHANDRA SHAKER | 14-06-2019 | 23-01-2023 | 03-07-2023 | List for hearing as per seriatim. |
17 | AFT-29 | INCORRECT PAY FIXATION BY NOTIONAL PAY METHOD FOR PRE- 2016 ARMED FORCES PENSIONERS (ARMY -1) | 1352/2020 | 94 | CDR SUDHIR DUA, COL RAMESH SHARMA (13-7-20) | 01-10-2020 | 30-10-2023 | 01-12-2023 | As the Ld. Principal Registrar is on official duty at AFT, Regional Bench, Mumbai, the Court has not assembled today. |
18 | AFT-29 | INCORRECT PAY FIXATION BY NOTIONAL PAY METHOD FOR PRE- 2016 ARMED FORCES PENSIONERS (ARMY-2) | 1539/2020 | 98 | CDR SUDHIR DUA, COL ARUN KUMAR SHARMA (1-8-2020) | 21-10-2020 | 03-10-2023 | 18-12-2023 | Four weeks time is sought on behalf of the respondents to file the counter affidavit not filed till date in terms of proceedings dated 22.10.2020 onwards, which be so filed within the said period of time as a last opportunity, failing which, right to file the same would stand automatically closed. Rejoinder, thereto, if any, be filed by the applicant within a period of four weeks thereafter. List the matter before the Principal Registrar on 18.12.2023 for completion of pleadings and before the Bench thereafter. |
19 | AFT-29 | INCORRECT PAY FIXATION BY NOTIONAL PAY METHOD FOR PRE- 2016 ARMED FORCES PENSIONERS (ARMY-3) | 1514/2020 | 100 | CDR SUDHIR DUA, LT COL RAMESH KUMAR SURI (29-7-2020) | 19-10-2020 | 25-10-2023 | 18-12-2023 | On behalf of the applicant, it is submitted that there are four similar cases, they may be heard together and it is submitted that an application in relation thereto would filed. 2. The matter be listed along with OA 1539/2020 for analogous hearing on 18.12.2023. |
20 | AFT-29 | INCORRECT PAY FIXATION BY NOTIONAL PAY METHOD FOR PRE- 2016 ARMED FORCES PENSIONERS (NAVY) | 1541/2020 | 95 | CDR SUDHIR DUA, CDR ISHWAR CHANDRA SHARMA (3-08-2020) | 21-10-2020 | 31-10-2023 | 21-12-2023 | The matter be re-notified for final hearing on 21.12.2023. |
21 | AFT-29 | INCORRECT PAY FIXATION BY NOTIONAL PAY METHOD FOR PRE- 2016 ARMED FORCES PENSIONERS (AIR FORCE) | 1547/2020 | 77 | CDR SUDHIR DUA, SQN LDR R K GUPTA (27-7-2020) | 21-10-2020 | 03-10-2023 | 08-01-2024 | MA 3345/2022 This is an application filed on behalf of the respondents for condonation of delay of 340 days in filing the counter affidavit. In view of the reasons explained and in the interest of justice, the delay in filing the counter affidavit is condoned. The MA is disposed of accordingly. OA 1547/2020 In view of the factum that the rejoinder thereto is also already on the record, the Counter affidavit filed by the respondents is taken on record. The matter be re-notified for final hearing on 08.01.2024. |
22 | AFT-20 | RECOVERY DUE TO NON SUBMISSION OF OPTION FORM TO COME UNDER 6TH CPC SCALES OF PAY | 1978/2020 | 33 | MAJ B BIKSHAPATHY SUB BIJENDER SINGH | 23-12-2020 | 02-01-2023 | 18-05-2023 | (No update) for final hearing |
23 | MSP- AR- ARMY-1 | ARREARS OF MSP FROM 01 JAN 2006 TO 31 AUG 2008 | 2929/2022 | 45 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, BRIG ANOOP KUMAR JAIRATH | 15-12-2022 | 12-09-2023 | 16-11-2023 | Learned counsel for the respondents prays for and is granted further four weeks’ time to file the counter affidavit. Rejoinder, if any, may be filed within two weeks thereafter. 2. List again on 16.11.2023. |
24 | MSP- AR- ARMY-2 | ARREARS OF MSP FROM 01 JAN 2006 TO 31 AUG 2008 | 3059/2022 | 45 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, LT GEN RAKESH CHANDRA CHADHA | 26-12-2022 | 29-09-2023 | 19-12-2023 | (No update) |
25 | MSP- AR- ARMY-3 | ARREARS OF MSP FROM 01 JAN 2006 TO 31 AUG 2008 | 2928/2022 | 10 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, HONY NB SUB JAGDISH PRASAD | 15-12-2022 | 12-09-2023 | 16-11-2023 | Learned counsel for the respondents prays for and is granted further four weeks’ time to file the counter affidavit. Rejoinder, if any, may be filed within two weeks thereafter. 2. List again on 16.11.2023. |
26 | MSP- AR- IN-1 | ARREARS OF MSP FROM 01 JAN 2006 TO 31 AUG 2008 | 2951/2022 | 18 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, CMDE RAVINDER DATTA | 15-12-2022 | 13-09-2023 | 04-12-2023 | Counsel for the respondents prays for and is granted four weeks’ time to file counter affidavit. Rejoinder, if any, be filed within two weeks thereafter. |
27 | MSP- AR- IN-2 | ARREARS OF MSP FROM 01 JAN 2006 TO 31 AUG 2008 | 2794/2022 | 2 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, HONY LT NEMI CHAND | 30-11-2022 | 18-10-2023 | 01-12-2023 | Counsel for the respondents prays for and is granted four weeks’ time to file counter affidavit as a matter of last indulgence. Rejoinder, if any, be filed within two weeks thereafter. List the matter for final hearing on 01.12.2023. |
28 | MSP- AR- IAF-1 | ARREARS OF MSP FROM 01 JAN 2006 TO 31 AUG 2008 | 2799/2022 | 6 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, GP CAPT P K RAGHAVAN | 01-01-2022 | 29-08-2023 | 15-11-2023 | Learned counsel for the respondents prays for and is granted further four weeks’ time to file the counter affidavit. Rejoinder, if any, may be filed within four weeks thereafter. 2. List again on 15.11.2023. |
29 | MSP- AR- IAF-2 | ARREARS OF MSP FROM 01 JAN 2006 TO 31 AUG 2008 | 2946/2022 | 3 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, SGT NARAYANA RAO PITTA | 15-12-2022 | 12-09-2023 | 16-11-2023 | Learned counsel for the respondents prays for and is granted further four weeks’ time to file the counter affidavit. Rejoinder, if any, may be filed within two weeks thereafter. 2. List again on 16.11.2023 |
Sl. No | Description | Case No. | Petitioner / Respondent | Filing Date | Listing Date | Status |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Implementation of One Rank One Pension 2018 with Financial Benefit from Jul 2019 Legal Brief Case details | WP20310/2021 | TSEWA / Union of India | 25-08-2021 | 28-10-2021 | PENDING |
2 | OROP - Contempt Case | CC 187/2022 | TSEWA / Union of India | 04-02-2022 | 25-03-2022 | Next Listing on 06/04/2022 |
Sl. No | Description | Dairy No. | Lead Litigant / Respondent | Filing Date | Present/Last Listed On | Next Hearing Date |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Civil Appeal - To get full Broad Banding arrears instead of three years. | 24184/2018 | LT COL R C DABRAL (RETD.) vs. UNION OF INDIA | 03-07-2018 | 03-12-2019 | 18-11-2022 |
2 | Special Leave Petition to get full Broad Banding arrears instead of three years. | 2165-2022 | LT. COL. MATHEW THOMAS / Union of India | 19-01-2022 | 21-02-2022 | 18-11-2022 |
SL NO | AFT CASE | DESCRIPTION | OA No. | No.of APPL | COORDINATOR & LEAD LITIGANT | DATE OF DISPATCH | CASE STATUS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | AFT-1B | ENHANCEMENT OF PENSION (OFFICERS) ARMY-1 | ARMY- 164 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, LT COL DARSHAN SINGH PANDHER | 10-02-2018 | Rem Judgement expected & awaited in OA 34/2016, Hence not filed. | |
2 | AFT-1B | ENHANCEMENT OF PENSION (OFFICERS) ARMY-2 | ARMY- 175 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, LT COL SUNIL BAWA | 10-02-2018 | Rem Judgement expected & awaited in OA 34/2016, Hence not filed. | |
3 | AFT-1B | ENHANCEMENT OF PENSION (OFFICERS) NAVY | NAVY-90 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, CDR BIMAL RAI BHATIA | 10-02-2018 | Rem Judgement expected & awaited in OA 34/2016, Hence not filed. | |
4 | AFT-1B | ENHANCEMENT OF PENSION (OFFICERS) AIR FORCE | AIR FORCE- 70 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA, WG CDR SAILESH RATTAN | 10-02-2018 | Rem Judgement expected & awaited in OA 34/2016, Hence not filed. | |
5 | AFT-5 | GETTING PENSION OF SEPOY TO WIVES OF DECEASED EX-SERVICEMEN(SEP-HAV) | 150 | LT COL G PARVATHESAM | 23-10-2017 | Document Under final Scrutiny with Advocate in Delhi | |
6 | AFT-6 (A) | GETTING PENSION OF COL (TS) TO ALL PRE-16 DEC 2004 LT COLS (Col-TS 2) | 178 | LT COL K P RADHAKRISHNAN, LT COL RAVINDER KUMAR CHADHA | 20-11-2017 | Rem Judgement expected & awaited in OA 664/2016, Hence not filed. | |
7 | AFT-9 | GETTING PENSION OF NB SUB TO POST -2006 HONY NB SUBS - (HNS-1A) | 13 | HONY CAPT B JOSEPH HONY NB SUB PREM SINGH | 17-05-2017 | Document Under final Scrutiny with Advocate in Delhi | |
8 | AFT-21 | INCORRECT PENSION FIXATION BY MINIMUM OF FITMENT TABLE FOR DELINKING OF 33 YEARS | 98 | BRIG C S VIDYASAGAR, SGT KALYAN SHARMA | 16-02-2018 | Document Under final Scrutiny with Advocate in Delhi | |
9 | AFT-28 | PAY FIXATION DISPARITY - MAJOR'S 5TH CPC (NAVY) | 16 | MAJ PM GOSWAMI, ---- | 31-01-2018 | Finding Lead litigant | |
10 | AFT-29 | INCORRECT PAY FIXATION BY NOTIONAL PAY METHOD FOR PRE- 2016 ARMED FORCES PENSIONERS (ARMY-4) | ARMY- 154 | CDR SUDHIR DUA, | 31-01-2018 | Document Under final Scrutiny with Advocate in Delhi | |
11 | AFT-30 | INCORRECT FIXATION OF PENSION BY NOTIONAL PAY METHOD AS ON JAN 2016 FOR PRE- 2016 JCOS AND ORS AND FAMILY PENSIONERS | 74 | LT COL K P RADHAKRISHNAN, HONY NB SUB CHANDRA SHEKHAR SINGH | 20-02-2018 | Document Under final Scrutiny with Advocate in Delhi | |
12 | AFT-17 | PENSION OF SEPOYS TO RESERVISTS | 13 | SMT HARJEET KAUR | 01-02-2019 | Saperate Case ARMY Lead Litigant required | |
13 | AFT-29B | INCORRECT PAY FIXATION BY NOTIONAL PAY METHOD FOR PRE- 2016 ARMED FORCES PENSIONERS | 49 | BRIG C S VIDYASAGAR | 13-12-2018 | Document Under final Scrutiny with Advocate in Delhi | |
14 | AFT-MSP | MILITARY SERVICE PAY - GENERAL OFFICERS | 102 | CMDE SUDHEER PARAKALA | 16-02-2022 | Documents sent to Advocate in Delhi |
SL NO | AFT CASE | OA No. | No.of APPL | COORDINATOR & LEAD LITIGANT | CASE STATUS | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | AFT-1C | ENHANCEMENT OF PENSION (OFFICERS) | 147 | BRIG C S VIDYASAGAR LEAD LITIGANT | Awaited instructions from Delhi for despatch of documents | ||
2 | AFT-28 B | PAY FIXATION DISPARITY - MAJOR'S 5TH CPC | 107 | Awaited instructions from Delhi for despatch of documents |
SL NO | AFT CASE | DESCRIPTION | OA No. | No.of APPL | COORDINATOR & LEAD LITIGANT | CASE STATUS | REMARKS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | AFT-4 | T-33, DROPPED | 549 | COL AJIT SINGH RANA | DROPPED | 1.FEW MEMBERS DONATED LEGAL FEE TO TSEWA. 2.LEGAL FEE REFUNDED WHERE MEMBERS ASKED FOR. |
|
2 | AFT-12 (A) | LT COL PENSION FOR PRE-1996 RETIREE MAJORS WITH MORE THAN 21 YEARS COMMISSIONED SERVICE | NIL | MAJ PM GOSWAMI | DROPPED | ||
3 | AFT-13 (A) | GETTING PENSION OF LT COLS TO ALL THOSE PRE - JAN 2000 MAJS WHO PUT IN 20 YEARS | NIL | MAJ PM GOSWAMI | DROPPED | ||
4 | AFT-14 (A) | GETTING PENSION OF LT COLS TO ALL PRE - 16 DEC 2004 MAJS | NIL | MAJ PM GOSWAMI | DROPPED | ||
5 | AFT-16 | GETTING PENSION OF LAST RANK EVEN THOUGH IT WAS NOT HELD FOR 10 MONTHS | 3 | DROPPED | |||
6 | AFT-18 | HIGHER PENSION TO MAJ'S OROP | NIL | DROPPED | |||
7 | AFT-22 | POST - OROP HONY OFFICERS GETTING LESS PENSION THAN THEIR COUNTER PARTS WHO RETIRED PRE- OROP | 65 | DROPPED |